Skip to main content

Apple Trounces Psystar in Court Ruling

Psystar logo
Image used with permission by copyright holder

It’s a legal fight that’s been brewing for over a year, but now a heavy hammer has come down: U.S. District Judge William Alsup has ruled categorically against Mac clone maker Psystar, finding the company violated Apple’s copyrights by pre-installing Mac OS X on its own Intel-based computers. The judge also threw out Psystar’s motions that Apple was misusing copyright law to monopolize a market, and that Psystar had the right to do anything it liked with Mac OS X under the “first sale” doctrine.

“Psystar has violated Apple’s exclusive reproduction right, distribution right, and right to create derivative works,” Judge Alsup wrote in his ruling (available as a PDF via Groklaw). “Accordingly, Apple’s motion for summary judgment on copyright infringement must be granted.” The ruling also found that Psystar violated the anti-circumvention and anti-trafficking provisions of the Digital Millennium Copyright Act (DMCA).

The ruling provides legal backbone to end-user license agreements (EULAs) included with most commercial software and operating systems. Apple’s EULA for Mac OS X restricts the software to use on Apple computers and specifically disallows using the operating system on non-Apple systems.

While the ruling is a sweeping victory for Apple—and few in the legal community expected any other outcome—it does not mean an end to the legal wrangling between Psystar and Apple: Judge Alsup did not rule on damages from copyright infringement, or on Apple’s claims involving trademark infringement, breach of contract, and other issues. Psystar also has a case pending against Apple in Florida, in which it claims Apple illegally ties Mac OS X 10.6 “Snow Leopard” to Apple hardware; however, in light of Judge Alsup’s ruling, Psystar’s Florida case seems like a very, very dim hope.

Editors' Recommendations

Topics
Geoff Duncan
Former Digital Trends Contributor
Geoff Duncan writes, programs, edits, plays music, and delights in making software misbehave. He's probably the only member…
Best Apple Studio Display deals: Save $300 on the 5K monitor
Apple Mac Studio and Studio Display.

If you're familiar with the Pro Display XDR, then you'll be happy to see its successor, the Apple Studio Display, which is actually significantly cheaper. Even so, the Studio Display is pretty powerful, with a high pixel density giving it a 5k resolution and making it perfect for graphics designers and similar. Unfortunately, even with the cheaper price, it's quite expensive, which is why we've found some great Apple Studio Display deals and listed them below, that way you can help save a bit extra.
Today's Best Apple Studio Display Deals

Apple Studio Display (Standard Glass Tilt Adjustable) --

Read more
How to erase and restore your Mac to factory settings
Apple MacBook Pro 16 front angled view showing display and keyboard.

Whether you’re looking to sell your Mac or reset it due to an intractable software problem, restoring your Mac to factory settings is a good way to spruce it up, clear off your personal information, and fix any lingering problems.

Read more
I write about laptop deals for a living — don’t miss these four today
The Dell XPS 13, open on a table in front of a window.

There are all kinds of laptop deals out there, so if you need help in narrowing down your choices, you should check out our top picks for today's bargains. We've got offers on laptops made by HP, Dell, and Apple, which are among the best laptop brands. This means you won't have to worry over how dependable these laptops will be, but you'll need to hurry with your decision on which one to purchase because we expect high demand for these devices.
HP Laptop 17t -- $300, was $500

Affordable laptops don't have to be small and slow, as evidenced by the HP Laptop 17t. Its 17.3-inch display with HD+ resolution is among the biggest screens that you can get on a laptop for any price, which is perfect for working on projects and watching streaming shows. The HP Laptop 17t is also capable of handling your daily activities with its Intel N200 processor, Intel UHD Graphics, and 8GB of RAM, with Windows 11 Home pre-loaded in its 256GB SSD.

Read more