Upgrade Exhaustion: Is The TV Industry Ripping Consumers Off?

upgrade exhaustion is the tv industry ripping consumers off old dump

I am really excited to have the opportunity to write a column for Digital Trends. I love technology, with particular interest in home audio and video, and can write about it all day. I work for Orb Audio, an online speaker company, and while I do think Orb is awesome, I will save self-promotion for another day.

For now, there is something I need to get off my chest. I think my industry has gone crazy! Absolutely off the cliff crazy. All of this talk about 3D TVs with Internet capabilities is exciting, but it overlooks the fact that consumers are being asked to replace not just TVs, but also receivers, HDMI cables and even DVD and Blu-ray players. Yes, the new specification for TV and HDMI is so different from the last one, that you can’t use a single thing in your current system, down to even the cables, if you want 3D and Internet capabilities.

I know, technology evolves and the shiny thing you buy is always instantly outdated. I get that. But this is different. First of all, I think it’s rude to ask people to replace all of the flat screen TVs that were sold in the last five years, especially in the current economic climate. But beyond that, it’s even worse that consumers will have to replace most of their equipment including cables if they want to take part in the “future” of TV. Couldn’t there have been slightly better planning? I don’t recall having to buy 1.0, 1.1, 1.3a, 1.3b and 1.4 versions of my RCA cables or other cables.

upgrade exhaustion is the tv industry ripping consumers off samsung 3d hdWhat it comes down to is that the industry has sold a ton of this stuff in the last five years, and it’s all been based on keeping mum about the fact none of it would work with the new standards that were being developed at the time.

So, how come no one told us when we were buying all of this great gear that it would be incompatible with their next generation of products and services that were just around the corner? Seriously – why did the industry spend so much time fluffing things like 240hz refresh rates and fake contrast ratios when none of that will matter if you want to watch the game in 3D, or use any of the Internet features now available in the new TVs?

None of this makes sense. Last year, the industry sold me a Blu-ray player and told me I needed it. This year, it tells me that I should get a new TV or receiver and just stream my video from the Internet, and to forget those pesky discs. But what if I like discs? Well, last year’s Blu-ray player won’t play 3D movies when they come out, so I’m out of luck there. And theoretically my receiver and TV can’t stream and share Internet because they aren’t HDMI 1.4 compatible. You might be able to use an old HDMI 1.3 cable to connect a 3D receiver to a 3D TV, but that doesn’t change the fact that you need a new 3D TV and a new 3D Blu-ray player. And, you will definitely need new HDMI 1.4 cables if you want Internet over HDMI.

Dare I even ask what HDMI 1.5 is or when it’s coming out? Is it being released the day after everyone buys enough HDMI 1.4 stuff to make a good profit? Will it cook my dinner?

Better yet, how can anyone even figure this stuff out? I’m still trying to get the last version of HDMI to work. I work in the industry. I’m an audio guy and a tech geek. So why is it after three years, I can’t get HDMI to work correctly with my cable box, TV and receiver? Equipment manufacturers need to spend more time playing nice with each other.

Here’s the scenario: From time to time, my TV goes blue and switches from high-definition to 480i resolution. It then switches back and forth, becoming unwatchable until I do “the fix.” Everything has a fix, usually a quirky one. In my case, the fix is to switch to a non-high-def channel and switch back. Thank you channel 91, whatever you are!

I’m told that what I’m experiencing probably comes down to issues with copy protection in HDMI, but who really cares? Just like anyone else, I want my stuff to work. I should plug the wires into the right spots and it should work. It really makes me mad that the industry was so worried about the pirating of movies (which is still supremely easy) that they introduced some scheme that interferes with the whole thing and messes up my experience.

Instead, couldn’t they have spent that time making sure they included data channels in the first HDMI specification to accommodate future features? That is really what it comes down to; the new version of HDMI has more data channels than the prior versions. Since all companies operate on roadmaps, and this Internet and 3D stuff had to be on everyone’s roadmap, would it have been that hard to just get the cable right the first time? Or the second, third or fourth time?

upgrade exhaustion is the tv industry ripping consumers off netflix blu rayConsumers are eventually going to lose faith, if they haven’t already. I was reading a review of the Sony PSP recently and one of the “pros” was that “Skype is said to work.” I think it’s both funny and sad that advertised features don’t always work and we now consider it a positive when features actually work. My business partner recently bought a so-called “Netflix-enabled” Blu-ray player, and guess what? The Netflix doesn’t work, and the manufacturer tells him it’s a “known issue.” Maybe he should throw it out, together with his TV and receiver, and start over, on the hope that this new specification will actually work.

The crazy thing is, WebTV was telling us a decade ago that we wanted Internet on the TV and we just didn’t listen. Or maybe the experience wasn’t good enough. But I do think it’s interesting that years after the relative demise of WebTV (they take no new subscribers), we are all being asked to buy new TVs and equipment so that we can get the Web on TV.

Anyhow, that’s my rant for now. I think the industry needs to be careful or they will exhaust or frustrate the consumer right out of the market and we will all keep our TVs and equipment 10 years or longer. How dare we!


Ethan Siegel is co-founder of Orb Audio, a U.S. based manufacturer of audio speakers and related equipment. Prior to forming Orb Audio, Ethan was an attorney in New York city. He has always been passionate about technology and used his first credit card in college to buy speakers that were way out of his price range.

The views expressed here are solely those of the author and do not reflect the beliefs of Digital Trends.

Home Theater

Netflix raised prices and lost customers. Can a mobile-only plan win them back?

As customers fled Netflix after its latest price hikes, the company announced that a mobile-only streaming plan is coming to India -- and, just maybe, revealed how it will get those subscribers back.
Home Theater

Everything coming to Apple TV+ that we know about so far

Here's everything we know is coming to Apple TV+, Apple's subscription video service, which already has an impressive lineup of original series and films in the works from some of Hollywood's biggest names.
Home Theater

New TV? Here's where to go to watch the best 4K content available

Searching for content for your new 4K UHD TV? Look no further. We have every major source of the best 4K content, along with the cost, hardware requirements, and features that make each service worth a look.
Deals

Walmart drops a great deal on this Samsung 50-inch 4K HDR TV

This 50-inch Samsung TV is currently priced at just $328 during Walmart's summer sale. With smart functionality, HDR, and beautiful 4K UHD resolution, you get a lot for that low of a price.
Deals

Walmart drops killer deals on TCL 4K Roku smart TVs after Prime Day

There are quite a few TCL 4K Roku TV deals going on at Walmart right now. With huge price cuts, many of these discounts are just as good, if not better, than Amazon's Prime Day TV deals.
Deals

This LG 75-inch 4K TV is one of the best deals going on a big-screen television

If you’re shopping for a big-screen television to enjoy your entertainment in Ultra HD and missed those Amazon Prime Day deals, then this LG 75-inch 4K TV deal is one of the best values right now on a large set for your home theater.
Deals

Amazon Prime Day deals are ending, but you can still get great bargains

Prime Day 2019 has come to an end for Amazon, but that doesn't mean the Prime Day deals are over. With deals from Walmart, Best Buy, and Amazon still going on, this massive shopping event is continuing on through the week.
Home Theater

The best Dolby Atmos movies for your home theater, from Us to Infinity War

If you've got your hands on some sweet Dolby Atmos gear, the next step is to find films that take advantage of it. These are our picks in several genres for the best Dolby Atmos movies currently available on Blu-ray and streaming services.
Home Theater

Is bigger really better? How to figure out what size TV you need

What size TV do you need? Here are a few tips for picking the right size, including where to find a TV’s measurements, ideal viewing distance, and picture quality versus size. Not sure what to look for? This guide is for you.
Deals

Walmart post-Prime Day sale: 4K TV, Apple, and Nintendo Switch deals

Prime Day 2019 has come to an end for Amazon, but that doesn't mean the deals are over. Walmart's Prime Day sale. Walmart's Prime Day sale lasts all day today, extending a whole extra day beyond Amazon's shopping extravaganza.
Deals

Walmart cuts price of this LG 65-inch 4K TV by $220 after Prime Day

In the market for a solid, budget-friendly 4K TV but missed out on the Prime Day offers? worry not. Walmart has an ongoing special summer sale on numerous 4K models, including the LG 65-inch Class 4K Ultra HD Smart LED HDR TV.
Cars

How Lexus, one of the industry’s hybrid champions, is preparing for the 2020s

Lexus predicts significant shifts will reshape the automotive industry during the 2020s. The hybrid champion is preparing to branch out into electric cars, it's investing in autonomous technology, and it wants to keep focusing on SUVs.
Home Theater

Sony WF-1000XM3 vs. Sennheiser Momentum vs. Klipsch T5 True Wireless headphones

We've been testing three of the most popular premium true wireless earbuds against each other. In our comparison of the Sony Wf-1000XM3, Sennheiser Momentum, and Klipsch T5 True Wireless, we compare sound, comfort, and style.
Deals

Grab the Dolby Dimensions wireless headphones for $200 less after Prime Day

Dolby has made its very first self-branded product in the form the Dolby Dimensions wireless headphones and as expected, it delivers. You can get the Dimensions on Amazon for $399 – $200 less than its normal retail price of $600.