Amazon Echo vs. Amazon Echo Show: The Show has a screen but is it worth the upgrade?

cortana
After much anticipation, Amazon has finally unveiled the latest in the Alexa-equipped Echo family, the Echo Show. While a 7-inch touchscreen means the unit isn’t the easiest on the eyes, the Show certainly has a few accessories absent from the standard Amazon Echo. Slapping a screen on the Echo certainly adds a welcome visual element to the experience, but many of Alexa’s Skills have yet to take full advantage, and many individuals may not need the added versatility. That said, is making the upgrade a worthy leap of faith? Here’s a rundown of the models to help you make the decision for yourself.

Skills and Functionality

Once the devices are set up and connected to the smartphone app, both the Echo and the Echo Show are equally capable of controlling all of your compatible smart-home appliances and accessories. When it comes to monitoring these smart-home devices, however, the Show has a clear advantage. Most notably, the Show can display feeds from smart-home cameras and video doorbells, like Nest, Arlo, Ring, and August.

Shopping on the Echo Show has a much more natural feel than it does on the standard Echo. For example, say “Alexa, order me some batteries,” and the Show screen will promptly display a full catalog of batteries to choose from. Give this same command to Echo and the device can only choose a pack for you or reorder batteries you’ve previously purchased — modest albeit significant dissimilarity.

This visual aspect is really what separates the two devices, and the ability to both hear and also see these cues adds clarity to the process. You won’t always need (or be able) to use the screen with some of the Amazon Skills, but those that do have video capability can be very helpful around the home or office. Mainstay Skills like YouTube are handy when it comes to watching music videos and even following along with lyrics of the latest hits (not that you can’t already do this with your phone or a basic tablet).

amazon echo show

The Food Network Skill is currently one of the more popular Skills for Amazon Echo. The utility allows individuals to easily follow along as Alexa guides them through simple or more extensive recipes. This Skill was updated specifically for Echo Show; not only will Alexa walk you through the prep work, she will also list instructions and play tutorial videos. We can only hope Amazon builds upon this with other Skills to make the device easier to use down the road. Similarly, the visual timer is a very useful tool when preparing meals in the kitchen. It’s not difficult to ask Alexa how much time is remaining, but simply being able to glance at a digital readout is much more convenient and free-flowing.

As anyone who has ever asked Alexa about upcoming showtimes around town can attest, listening to a droning list of movie times can be frustrating, if not all out mind-numbingly reminiscent of Moviefone. Thankfully, with the Echo Show, Alexa will display a scrollable list of movies and showtimes, and will even play trailers for your perusing pleasure. When it comes to dressing and planning for the weather, the screen allows you to view weekly and hourly forecasts. The Echo Show will actively let you visualize and tweak your shopping lists, notes, and to-do lists for a more organic hands-on feel.

At the moment, many of the third-party Skills are a little wonky and do not fully capitalize on the visual component of the Show. Amazon claims that “third-party Skills had not yet been finalized for the Echo Show,” according to the New York Times. For the time being, we’ve compiled a list of our favorite Skills — feel free to enable the Digital Trends Skill.

Winner: Echo Show

Echo-to-Echo communication

Both devices are capable of Alexa-to-Alexa messaging and voice-calling between individuals with an Echo device and the compatible Alexa app, but only the Echo Show can handle video calling. This may sound like a wonderful addition to the Echo platform — and it is, mostly. There is a downfall, however. The Drop In feature, the technological equivalent of the pop-in, allows your contacts to call in whenever they want, and you don’t get the choice to decline them. You only have a few seconds to prepare for the call if someone does in fact “Drop In.” This brings up a slew of privacy concerns; as is the case with the Echo and Echo Dot, you can easily mute the Show and also block the camera.

Winner: Echo Show

Sound

Both the Echo and the Echo Show are more than capable of adequately hearing and communicating with you from the other side of larger spaces and also filling a room with music. It is important to note that neither of these speakers is a top of the line, stand-alone audio system, and pickier audiophiles will certainly have their complaints. However, connecting the line-up of Alexa-enabled devices to higher-end Bluetooth speakers will shore up these minor technological drawbacks. We’ve compiled a list of the best Bluetooth speakers on the market to further bolster your Alexa-centered home audio system.

Winner: Draw

Design

To be blunt, neither the Echo nor the Echo Show are sexy gadgets, and Amazon probably isn’t holding its breath on winning any International Design Excellence Awards anytime soon. Existing as a bland black monolith, the Amazon Echo is anything but an inspiring focal point in a given room. Similarly, with a clunky build, the Echo Show looks like it was created from leftover bulk components from Amazon Prime Day 2016 rather than a nod to the inevitable Jetsons smart-home of tomorrow. However, the 7-inch touchscreen does add functionality and a modest aesthetic touch without looking nearly as utilitarian as the Echo.

Winner: Echo Show

Our Take

The on-screen capabilities of the Echo Show aren’t necessarily must-haves right now, but as the Skills begin to cater to the Show platform, we should begin to see more functionality in the months ahead.

Beyond the nitpicky but relevant aesthetic flaws of each, there are some noteworthy design drawbacks with the Echo Show. For example, the Echo Show screen is always on in some form or fashion. You can ask Alexa to turn it off, but the screen will simply dim and display the time with the background still illuminated. Similarly, if the built-in camera detects motion, the screen will again turn on. For this reason, those who are sensitive to lighting at night will certainly not appreciate this temperamental nightlight in their bedrooms.

The Echo is available for $180 and the Echo Show costs $230 — it’s the priciest in the Echo family. That said, at just $50 more than the standard Amazon Echo, the Show is certainly worth the upgrade. But if you’re simply looking to add a little music to a room and occasionally pester a digital assistant without attempting to control your full array of smart appliances, then the basic Echo will surely suffice.

Winner: Echo Show

Buy now from Amazon:

Echo Echo Show

Smart Home

Amazon shows off compact cashier-free store that could show up at airports

Amazon is testing its smallest Amazon Go store to date as it considers taking the grab-and-go technology to new venues such as airports and train stations. The compact store is a quarter the size of its current locations.
Deals

Today’s best Amazon deals: Echo Dot, Fitbit, and Anker

Black Friday and Cyber Monday may be over, but for retail giants like Amazon, the savings are only getting started. We've scoured the depths of Amazon to find you the very best deals going on right now.
Deals

Sign up for Verizon Fios Triple Play and get a free Amazon Echo, Prime for a year

Verizon is now offering its Fios Gigabit Connection Custom TV and Phone service with Amazon Prime tossed in. While valid, you can sign up for the company’s Triple Play package, which includes all three Fios services, for $80 per month.
Movies & TV

'Prime'-time TV: Here are the best shows on Amazon Prime right now

There's more to Amazon Prime than free two-day shipping, including access to a number of phenomenal shows at no extra cost. To make the sifting easier, here are our favorite shows currently streaming on Amazon Prime.
Smart Home

These accessories take your already awesome Instant Pot to a whole new level

If you're familiar with the Instant Pot, you know that this bad boy acts as a pressure cooker, rice cooker, cake maker, egg boiler, and a lot more. Here are some must-have accessories to make Instant Pot cooking even better.
Smart Home

Cops go after porch pirates with dummy Amazon boxes and GPS trackers

Amazon is helping police in Jersey City to catch thieves who steal delivered packages from outside people's homes. Within just minutes of the operation's launch this week, cops nabbed their first porch pirate.
Smart Home

Amazon sent me a Christmas tree. Did it leave me pining for more?

Is driving to a Christmas tree lot or farm to get some fresh pine a daunting task that you dread every year? Good news: Amazon is now selling real Christmas trees with free shipping. We decided to order one to see how it went.
Smart Home

A couple’s recalled dishwasher caught on fire — and now they’re warning others

A Wisconsin couple has been using the dishwasher in their house for a year, unaware that it was recalled in 2009. Then the appliance caught fire. Now they are warning others to check appliances for risks when buying or renting a home.
Smart Home

Amazon has some killer deals on vacuums through the holidays

Whether you're buying for someone else or for yourself, Amazon has some great deals on vacuums running through the holidays. Score them while you can and keep your home cleaner than ever.
Smart Home

Got an Emerson thermostat? 135,000 of them are being recalled due to fire risk

Most recalls are relatively benign but if you own an Emerson-branded thermostat, we encourage you to check your model number because the company has alerted consumers to the potential of the device starting a fire.
Deals

You don't want to sleep on these red-hot bedding deals

We've rounded up some of the best discounts and sales happening right now, so you can buy yourself (or your loved ones) new bedding without breaking your budget. Trust us when we say these are deals worth losing sleep over.
Deals

Best deals for smart home plugs that control your lights and appliances

Smart hubs and speakers play central communication and management roles in your home, but smart plugs let you add lights and appliances to your system. Any smart plug you buy must support one feature or anything you plug in stays dumb.
Mobile

G’day, Google: U.S. users can now give Assistant a British or Australian accent

U.S. Google Assistant users can give their Assistant a different voice. Google has updated Assistant with the ability for users to give it either a British or Australian accent, which could make it a little more personal for some.
Smart Home

Knock, knock. Who's there? With a video doorbell, you'll never have to guess

When it comes to knowing who's at your door before you actually open it, there's nothing better than a video doorbell. Plus, you can "answer" the door even if you're not home. Here are some of our favorites.