Extortion or honesty? ReviewerCard is a gut check for the online review ecosystem

reviewercard i write reviewsThat awkward palm-full-of-cash-handshake for a better booth at dinner is about to be so 2012. Now, all you have to do to get the treatment you deserve is flash a little black card – with an online review profile to back it up.

ReviewerCard is an idea launched recently by Brad Newman. It alerts business owners that you are a Yelper, a Foursquare addict, a TripAdvisor user, Urbanspooner – whatever. You are someone who plans to write about their service online, and a simple flick of the card (which is free, should your application be accepted) let’s them know you should be treated accordingly.

reviewercard how it worksNewman says he has barely talked to the press since launching ReviewerCard – and you can’t really blame him. After announcing the product, he and his startup recieved a healthy, heaping serving of criticism.

“I can only hope that businesses see [ReviewerCard] for what it is,” wrote the L.A. Times. “A shameless bid to extract personal favors under threat of Internet ruin. I can only hope they politely inform ReviewerCard holders that they’re entitled to the same treatment as all other customers.”

Yelp doesn’t have kind words for the business either. “Asking businesses for special treatment or free services in exchange for a review of your experience violents our Terms of Service and can violate Federal Trade Commission guidelines,” a spokesperson tells me. “We are also heartened to see that members of our community are bashing the idea within Yelp talk threads.

“Anyone who read that first article jumped on the bandwagon,” Newman, who has been banned from a handful of review sites, says of the complaints.

The attacks aren’t entirely without merit. The basis of ReviewerCard is jarring, to say the least, and pieces of the L.A. Times interview with Newman are discouraging (i.e., the time Newman whipped out the card and asked for a discounted hotel room in exchange for a good review). There’s something about the whole idea that just rubs you the wrong way: If you’re someone who reviews local businesses, all you have to do is flash the card to let the respective business know that you will be writing up its service – thus ensuring you get preferential treatment. It’s just… not… fair.

But before we dive into what’s wrong with ReviewerCard, Newman wants to explains what’s right. “I’ve never written a bad review for a business. I can’t bring myself to do it – because I know how detrimental it is for them,” he says. “Someone can get fired or go out of business because of a bad review.”

“Businesses are funny. I’d get solicited by business owners asking me to mention their name or write a review about them, saying they’d give me a discount or something for it. Why are businesses allowed to solicit us? Why don’t we turn the tables?”

Regardless of the gut reactions, Newman has a point: There have been a myriad of issues within the online review market. A lawsuit in which a writer was sued for writing a negative Yelp review about a business comes to mind, and the same site is still working to clear its reputation after being accused of extorting businesses in a cash-for-ratings scandal.

Because of all this, businesses remain at the mercy of consumers – which, in a sense, is how it should be. Local review sites are an increasingly used source when we decide where to eat, shop, get our hair cut. The proliferation and importance of these platforms means that anyone and everyone gets a voice, no expertise required. How many Foursquare users are trained food critics? How many Yelpers have a palette refined enough to judge wine? It doesn’t matter: The idea is that businesses are being watched, and the result is supposed to be that not only do we have a database of information helping us make location-based decisions, we can also report back. And the fact that businesses know we have that power could be guaranteeing better service because they never know who’s going to write that searing (or glowing) review.

For all its criticism of Newman’s rewards card, Yelp offers frequent reviewers its own perks via the Yelp Elite Squad, like invites to parties and other events hosted. But the benefits come from Yelp – not local businesses that fear online derision – and members frown upon flaunting their status for better service. “I wrote reviews before I became ‘Elite,'” a friend who’s an Elite Yelper tells me. “I don’t write reviews to be Elite. My motivation for writing reviews isn’t for free stuff, and I know a lot of other Yelpers feel that way too. It’s like being a food critic – you don’t see them going around saying ‘Hey, I’m a food critic, and I’m coming to your restaurant, so give me the best experience possible.’ There’s a good reason for that.”

reviewercard commentsOf course, when you give power to the Internet, you also realize how terrible the Internet can be. While there are many, many users who write thoughtful, accurate business reviews, there are also many opportunities for error: People with personal vendettas against the local coffee shop; someone who once got a bad haircut and has decided to vilify the entire staff; a customer who gets the name of the rude waiter wrong – and writes about it online.

The examples are unending. Hundreds of businesses took legal action against TripAdvisor in the U.K. over what they saw as unfair reviews. In one instance, a bed and breakfast with formerly positive reviews was accused of having a racist owner – an attack difficult to come back from. Very recently, FTC complaints were filed against Yelp, and it was called the “thug of the Internet” by a beleaguered business owner.

“The most frequent complaint lodged against Yelp was the company’s alleged practice of trading positive reviews for money,” MuckRock, a site that enables you to file Freedom of Information requests, says. “Business owners charged that Yelp called businesses to sell advertising on the site for $300-$350 per month… if a business declined the offer to advertise, complaints say Yelp deleted the positive reviews on that business’ page, claiming that the site had updated its ‘automated algorithm’ to reflect a ‘truer’ sense of the overall reviews.”

Clearly, the problem goes deeper and back further than ReviewerCard. It didn’t start the “threat of Internet ruin” businesses have to worry about. The Internet did. And in playing devil’s advocate, you could see the idea as a more honest approach to a situation we’re already deeply entrenched in.

“I just feel like the most important thing is the card is supposed to protect consumers and businesses. It’s never been about making money,” Newman tells me. “It’s about giving reviewers more joy – the mere presence of the card in the market raises the level of customer service.”

While Newman won’t reveal how many cards have been issued and are being used, he did tell me about the screening process. The ReviewerCard team is comprised of dedicated online reviewers, people who have worked in the service industry, and as he puts it, “people who were originally against the idea to begin with, but now get the merit of it. We want to have both sides of the dialogue.”

Newman isn’t the first to come up with the idea of leveraging status for service. The online service scores you based on your social-media presence, and has come under fire frequently for allegedly turning consumers who know how to use Twitter into bullies who want freebies. Klout also introduced the whole card scheme, enabling Passbook integration so users could make their own digital Klout card to “show off [their] influence to get special service and experiences.” And of course there are the tales of getting into night clubs and VIP airline lounges based on Klout. While plenty have cried foul, plenty have also redeemed these perks – they’re the ones telling us about them.

Still, Newman admits the ReviewerCard launch was not without fault. “I understand the product was not presented perfectly,” he says. “Like any entrepreneur you have to pivot and react to what the marketplace is saying. We get it, and we’re trying to make it right for everyone, review sites, businesses, consumers, everyone.”

According to Newman, despite the negative reactions, there has been an overwhelming amount of interest. “The online press is scary how bad it’s been, but the amount of applications from around the world is amazing,” he says. Not only are consumers interested in getting their own cards, but he says review sites have also contacted him to get involved (he declined to name them).

Next for ReviewerCard is to keep issuing the product to the “people who are deserving,” as Newman says, and growing the market in the U.S. and then internationally. The company will also be developing its offline community by holding events for members.

ReviewerCard is not enabling local shoppers with review site accounts to become bullies – that opportunity came with the advent of Web 2.0. And you have to wonder what the reaction would have been if Yelp or Foursquare introduced this product, some sort of way to notify businesses you were a reviewer or someone who checked-in to locations frequently. There would certainly be the early “this is wrong” outrage, but would it have subsided, with the widespread adoption of the new feature to follow? Leveraging social influence is no one’s fault but our own; it’s an ecosystem built on imagined celebrity and full of narcisstic undertones, tinged with more than a hint of self-entitlement. For better or worse, the mechanics of online reviews meant it was always going to lead to this.

Home Theater

Looking for a podcast? Pandora’s Podcast Genome Project is just the ticket

Pandora has created a brand new service for podcast listeners. Powered by calls the Podcast Genome Project, the new podcast offering uses an advanced combination of algorithms and human curation to deliver the perfect podcasts for you.
Gaming

Everything we know about 'Anthem', including new details on Javelin classes

BioWare announced an upcoming action role-playing game called 'Anthem' at EA Play 2017. Here's everything we know about the game so far, including gameplay, DLC, and when you'll be able to play it.
Emerging Tech

Quantum-based accelerometer can locate objects without GPS

Researchers have created a quantum "compass" that allows navigation without satellites. The instrument, technically called a standalone quantum accelerometer, is small enough to be transportable and has a very high level of accuracy.
Cars

Roborace wants human drivers and machines to work together

Roborace believes the future of racing is autonomous, but it's keeping human drivers in the picture for now. For its first race season, Roborace will use a car called DevBot 2.0 that can be driven by humans or machines.
Computing

Urban legends for the digital age: The best scary stories from the internet

In need of some simple scares this Halloween? We've combed the internet for the best creepypastas, urban legends, and scary stories. From found footage YouTube videos to a deceptively scary wiki, these stories are sure to spook.
Mobile

WhatsApp finally gives in to the lure of cash-generating ads

WhatsApp's co-founders always said their messaging app would never show ads, but once the pair quit the company, it seemed inevitable that its owner, Facebook, would find a way to incorporate them.
Mobile

Shazam hooks up with Instagram Stories for another way to share songs

The latest update for Apple-owned Shazam lets iPhone users share music tracks to Instagram Stories in a few quick taps. To enable the feature, just make sure you have the latest version of Shazam loaded on your handset.
Social Media

Dine and dash(board): Make a Yelp reservation from your car’s control panel

Already in the car, but can't decide where to eat? Yelp Reservations can now be added to some dashboard touchscreens. Yelp Reservations searches for restaurants within 25 miles of the vehicle's location.
Computing

Hackers sold 120 million private Facebook messages, report says

Up to 120 million private Facebook messages were being sold online by hackers this fall. The breach was first discovered in September and the messages were obtained through unnamed rogue browser extensions. 
Web

Switch up your Reddit routine with these interesting, inspiring, and zany subs

So you've just joined the wonderful world of Reddit and want to explore it. With so many subreddits, however, navigating the "front page of the internet" can be daunting. You're in luck -- we've gathered 23 of the best subreddits to help…
Social Media

Facebook opens pop-up stores at Macy’s, but they’re not selling the Portal

Facebook has opened pop-up stores at multiple Macy's, though they're not selling Facebook's new Portal device. Instead, they're showcasing small businesses and brands that are already popular on Facebook and Instagram.
Social Media

Facebook Messenger will soon let you delete sent messages

A feature coming to Facebook Messenger will let you delete a message for up to 10 minutes after you send it. The company promised the feature months ago and this week said it really is on its way ... "soon."
Social Media

Pinterest brings followed content front and center with full-width Pin format

Want to see Pinterest recommendations, or just Pins from followed users? Now Pinners can choose with a Pinterest Following feed update. The secondary feed eliminates recommendation and is (almost) chronological.
Smart Home

Facebook's Alexa-enabled video-calling devices begin shipping

Facebook's Portal devices are video smart speakers with Alexa voice assistants built in that allow you to make calls. The 15-inch Portal+ model features a pivoting camera that follows you around the room as you speak.