Skip to main content

Aereo sues CBS in pre-emptive move to protect Boston expansion

Aereo on iPad
Image used with permission by copyright holder

After weeks of legal threats from CBS and Fox, Aereo pre-empted any potential attempt by the broadcasting incumbents to stave off its planned expansion to Boston next week by filing a lawsuit against CBS today.

Only two weeks ago, Aereo unveiled its plan to expand its streaming service to Boston, leading to a feisty rebuke from CBS chief executive, Les Moonves, who accused the upstart company of “taking our signal” and threatened to take the network to cable only should the courts not stop Aereo’s operations and expansion. 

In the filing with the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York, Aereo cited CBS’ recent legal threats as a basis for asking the court to rule that its technology doesn’t infringe on anything CBS owns copyright to. Aereo announced that Boston would be the first city outside of its home base in New York to get the service. A further 21 markets across the country are to follow over the course of this year.

CBS was none too pleased about the move to Boston, and threatened to file suit there and in every other market Aereo goes to, based on comments from Moonves and tweets expressing similar sentiments by another CBS executive.

The district court actually denied a preliminary injunction against Aereo by CBS. Had it been awarded, the injunction would’ve stopped Aereo from expanding while the court heard the broadcaster’s case against the streaming service’s business model. CBS appealed, only to lose again at the Second Circuit Court of Appeals.

The war of words continued with official statements released yesterday.

“The fact that CBS did not prevail in their efforts to enjoin Aereo in their existing federal lawsuit does not entitle them to a do-over in another jurisdiction,” said Aereo in its statement. “We are hopeful that any such efforts to commence duplicative lawsuits to try to seek a different outcome will be rejected by the courts.”

“These public relations and legal maneuvers do not change the fundamentally illegal nature of Aereo’s supposed business,” CBS said in its statement. “The issue of unauthorized streaming of copyrighted television programming is now being contested in the 2nd Circuit and the 9th Circuit, and wherever Aereo attempts to operate there will be vigorous challenges to its illegal business model.”

Fox did not publicly comment on Aereo’s move, nor did any other broadcasters. The ongoing legal battle looks to continue in earnest with each successive market Aereo plans to expand to, mainly because the broadcasters contend that Aereo takes a TV signal they offer free over-the-air and sells it to subscribers without consent or compensation. There are also grievances over advertising revenue and recording content that allows viewers to fast-forward past commercials.

Editors' Recommendations

Ted Kritsonis
A tech journalism vet, Ted covers has written for a number of publications in Canada and the U.S. Ted loves hockey, history…
Samsung just knocked $200 off this massive 85-inch 4K TV
The Samsung 75-inch LED 4K Smart TV on a media cabinet.

Samsung is well-known for its smartphones and TVs; we're always amazed at the tech and price tag whenever we see them. For example, this 85-inch UHD CU7000 class is massive, but its regular price is a whopping $1,300, which is often too much to ask of folks. Luckily, Samsung has an excellent deal with a $200 discount, bringing it down to a slightly more palatable $1,100, which is still quite a bit of money until you remember it's for a massive 85-inch Samsung TV. As such, this is one of our favorite Samsung TV deals this week and well worth a grab if you want a big-screen TV.

Why you should buy the 85-inch Crystal UHD CU7000
Under the hood, the UHD CU7000 runs the Crystal Processor 4K, one of their better processors, which gives you a lot of great features, such as 4k upscaling so that you can watch your older content without an issue. Similarly, beyond just getting the typical HDR, you also get HLG, a type of HDR most broadcasters use, especially sports broadcasters. As such, if you're a sports fan, this is a great TV for both its size and HLG support. You also get PurColor, a technology that covers a wider section of the color gamut, giving you better colors than a traditional TV at a lower or similar price point. Another feature we like is the Q-Symphony, which lets you sync up any other Q-series or S-Series Samsung soundbars you might have to create a really impressive surround sound feeling.

Read more
Earfun makes hi-res audio more accessible with affordable earbuds and DAC
Earfun EH100 hi-res audio wired IEMs.

Earfun, a company known primarily for its ultra-affordable yet high-quality wireless earbuds and Bluetooth speakers, has launched two new products designed to get folks into the world of hi-res audio at a fraction of the price that its competitors charge. The Earfun EH100 ($100) are a set of triple-driver in-ear monitors (IEMs) with swappable tuning nozzles and the Earfun EA100 ($80) is a tiny digital-to-analog converter (DAC) and headphone amp with dual headphone jacks for both balanced and unbalanced connections.

These are already pretty affordable prices, however, between October 2 and October 15, you can buy one or both at a significant discount. The price for each product has been discounted by 30% ($70 for the EH100 and $56 for the EA100), or you can buy them as a bundle and save 35% ($117 for the EH100 and EA100).

Read more
TV deal: Get this Vizio 50-inch 4K TV for under $300 (selling fast)
The Vizio V-Series 4K TV in the living room.

If you've always wanted to upgrade your home theater setup with a large TV, then you may not want to miss Walmart's offer for the 50-inch Vizio V-Series 4K TV. It's down to just $248 after a $71 discount on its original price of $319. The bargain is one of the retailer's most popular TV deals with more than 500 units sold over the past 24 hours, which means you're going to have to hurry with your purchase as there's a chance that stocks don't last long.

Why you should buy the 50-inch Vizio V-Series 4K TV
The Vizio V-Series 4K TV offers 4K Ultra HD resolution, which will let you watch your favorite shows and movies with sharp details and lifelike colors, while its full array backlight with evenly distributed LEDs promises superior light uniformity. This amazing picture performance combines with DTS Virtual: X that creates immersive audio for a truly cinematic experience from the comfort of your own living room. If you want even better sound, the Vizio V-Series 4K TV is designed to seamlessly work with Vizio soundbars like the Vizio M-Series All in One, which we've highlighted in our roundup of the best soundbars.

Read more