Skip to main content

Digital Trends may earn a commission when you buy through links on our site. Why trust us?

You Asked: The Editor’s Cut — Is subscription culture out of control?

 
Promotional image of Caleb Denison for You Asked.
Each week, we'll hand pick some of the most commonly asked questions and answer them as concisely and helpfully as we know how.
Updated less than 4 days ago

Welcome to a special edition of You Asked: The Editor’s Cut! Today, we’re diving into a topic that’s shaping how we access tech, entertainment, and even everyday essentials: subscription culture. Caleb Denison is joined by three expert editors from Digital Trends who will help unpack the pros, cons, and quirks of this pervasive trend.

What is subscription culture?

Subscription culture represents a major shift in consumer behavior. Instead of purchasing products outright, people are increasingly opting to pay recurring fees to access them. This shift promises convenience and flexibility — no need for long-term commitments, just the freedom to come and go as we please. But is this trend delivering on its promises, or has it gone too far?

To help answer this, Caleb invited three of his colleagues to discuss their insights on the topic:

  • Nick Mokey, Editor-in-Chief, known for his passion for tech and adventurous spirit (including his side project building geodesic domes).
  • Giovanni Colantonio, Gaming Editor, also renowned for his clever Halloween costumes.
  • Luke Larsen, Computing Editor and unabashed Star Wars enthusiast (also named after Luke Skywalker).

Subscription models: where they shine and where they fall short

Our discussion kicked off with each editor sharing two examples of subscription models — one within their field and one outside it. From music and gaming to cloud computing and more, they highlighted subscriptions that offer genuine value and others that fall short of expectations.

Nick, Giovanni, and Luke provided firsthand insights into which subscriptions enhance user experience and which ones seem to prioritize profit over value. This led to a spirited debate on the growing number of subscription-based services and whether consumers truly benefit from them.

We also discussed the fact that cloud storage subscriptions have somehow become a passive enabler of digital hoarding. You don’t want to miss the part of this episode in which we learn just how many emails Nick Mokey has sitting in his inbox — it’s a staggering number.

Be sure to watch to the end as our crew pivots from talking about what’s wrong with subscription culture to a discussion about what we might be able to do about it.

All in all, we think this is a topic that will resonate with just about everyone.

Caleb Denison
Digital Trends Editor at Large Caleb Denison is a sought-after writer, speaker, and television correspondent with unmatched…
You Asked: What to expect at CES (that Caleb can answer)
You Asked CES

On today’s You Asked: As many of your questions about CES and what to expect (that I can possibly answer).

There have been so many good questions this week, it’s been hard to choose.
The future of sound
Samsung Q990C Digital Trends

Read more
You Asked: Black bar mystery solved and virtual mode explained
You Asked

On today’s You Asked: Why dumb TVs are practically extinct and what it means for you. Plus, we dive into what Samsung’s virtual mode really does in its soundbars and tackle the age-old question: Why do some movies have black bars on certain streaming services but not others — even when it’s the same movie?
Black bars: sometimes there, sometimes not

Saud writes: I have a question that’s been frustrating me for a while. I have an LG G4 77-inch OLED. Some movies and shows fill my entire TV screen (no black bars), while others don’t. For example, while watching the John Wick series on Lionsgate Play, the first three movies were full screen, but John Wick: Chapter 4 had black bars. Why is that? It feels frustrating and even disappointing when the full screen isn’t used -- like I’m not getting the most out of my TV. I’ve read this has to do with aspect ratios, but is it really the director’s choice, or are streaming platforms altering content to fit? If they do adjust it, does that affect the viewing experience?

Read more
You Asked: soundbar space woes and best big TV bets
You Asked Ep 71

On today’s You Asked: What if your soundbar blocks the bottom of your TV? What’s the best, biggest TV I would personally buy for $5,000? What’s the best-sounding bedroom TV for dialogue clarity?
When you need more soundbar space

Peter from Prague currently has an older 32-inch TV with a central pedestal stand sitting atop his Blu-ray player. That arrangement allows for the five inches of clearance needed to accommodate their 5-inch-tall soundbar system. Peter is looking to upgrade their TV and has noticed that most stands don’t leave much clearance between the bottom of the TV and whatever it sits on. What are his options?

Read more