Hands-On: Microsoft Kinect a Major Let Down

hands on microsoft kinect a major let down playing with at e3 2010

First there were Atari’s paddles. Then D-pads, analog sticks, and rumble packs. While most innovations in controller design have incrementally boosted the number of buttons, triggers and other inputs crammed into a two-handed brick, Microsoft’s Kinect promises to do away with them forever.

The unprecedented hands-free control device that Microsoft introduced last year as Project Natal has finally gotten a real name (Kinect), a price ($150) and a launch date (November 4). More importantly, it also has real games. After jumping, ducking and flailing along with many of the new titles for Kinect, including Ubisoft’s Motion Sports and Warner Bros.’ Game Party, it’s easy to see the appeal, but the execution remains a troubling question mark.

Put Down the Plastic

Gaming journalists seldom like to admit it, but stepping up to an E3 demo with even the most familiar controller carries with it a certain sense of anxiety. What does square do? Is left trigger brake or accelerate? Do I need to invert the Y axis? It’s the same sense of confusion and uncertainty that turns your parents, grandparents and skeptical friends away from video games. And though vets only feel it for a second with new games, it still exists.

Kinect bulldozes that sense of intimidation. Without a piece of plastic to pick up, hold properly, or otherwise fumble with, stepping into the game isn’t even a choice anymore. By the time you’re watching a game, you’re controlling it.

hands on microsoft kinect a major let down motion sportsUbisoft Motion Sports Test

In Motion Sports, the menus are dead simple. Every activity has been sorted into a grid on the main screen, which players can select from by merely holding their hand up and leaving it on the right one for a few seconds. A glowing profile of the player in the back of the screen makes it obvious which game you’re reaching for.

A few claps through the instruction screens, and you’re into the action.


We started out with football, which would seem like an awfully complex sport to distill down into just movement. Ubisoft did it by reducing the game to merely dodging incoming defenders as you race for a touchdown. You don’t run in place, steer your character, or cradle a virtual ball. Just perform the right movement – dodge, jump, duck – at the right moment, and you’ll make it to the end zone.

hands on microsoft kinect a major let down motion sport football

It’s like Dance Dance Revolution without the music – and surprisingly difficult to master. We found ourselves crunching into the turf over and over, either from performing the wrong moves, or just doing them too late. The delay of the Kinect system makes itself most obvious when jumping, which feels like it happens on screen a full second after you’ve done it in real life. Your feet are already planted firmly back on the carpet by the time it registers.

Even if we had a little more luck with it, we can’t see this type of gameplay keeping anyone – even a casual gamer lured in by the Kinect – occupied for very long. Besides a few extra points for exceptionally clean maneuvers, its sheer monotony.


Unlike football, Ubisoft’s skiing game actually lets you steer. The motion itself is mostly in the shoulders, while crouching controls speed (lower is faster) and clawing away at virtual ski poles lets you push off from a standstill.

Out of the gate, steering feels awkward. Although heeding the game’s instructions not to oversteer allows us not to run off the track immediately, it the character’s on-screen motions steel feel choppy and disconnected from our own. He almost seems to move in notches. Hardly the graceful carving motion you imagine with skiing.

hands on microsoft kinect a major let down motion sports sking

The pacekeeping avatar that picks all the perfect lines passed us in an instant and disappeared over the next hill. Even if you can manage to stay between the gates, picking those same razor-thin lines using your shoulders to steer feels like using a butterknife to perform surgery.

Root Beer Tapper, Quarterback Challenge and more

Other titles followed a similar pattern. Warner Bros.’ Game Party offered the same dismal sense of control with graphics and kiddie themes more suited for the Wii. The only trolls we hit in the Whack a Troll game were by accident, we sloshed soda everywhere and made quite a few digital customers angry in Root Beer Tapper, and Quarterback Challenge proved to be nearly impossible.

hands on microsoft kinect a major let down e3 2010Lots of Sizzle, Where’s the Steak?

One year ago, the sloppy and generally imprecise experiences we had with Kinect could have been passed off as pre-alpha buginess. But this is the state of Kinect in 2010, just months away from launch. With a full extra year of development under its belt, we’re not impressed with what we’ve seen.

The Kinect is not easy to use, it’s not accurate, and it’s not fun. The only worse waste of $150 we can imagine spending on the Kinect at this point is the ensuing trickle of dollars that would go into buying the present selection of godawful titles for it.

If there’s any potential for Kinect, it probably lies in its use as a tool for controlling menus. The few opportunities we had to interact with it on this level – rather than in games – it actually offered enough precision to not only work, but work well. If it can maintain that feel from a couch, reaching for the remote could become a thing of the past.

Nintendo really has a leg up on Microsoft here, and the Sony Move is definitely looking more promising at this point.


Still trying to unlock your main in 'Super Smash Bros. Ultimate'? Try these tips

Super Smash Bros. Ultimate is Nintendo’s biggest entry in the series to date with over 70 characters to unlock, but the process can feel tiresome. Here are our tips to unlock your roster as quickly as possible.

You're not a true fan without these Nintendo Switch exclusives

Who doesn't love a good Nintendo game? If you're looking for great first-party titles for your Nintendo Switch, take a look at our list of the very best exclusives available right now.

Apple Mac users should take a bite out of these awesome games

Contrary to popular belief, there exists a bevy of popular A-list games compatible for Mac computers. Take a look at our picks for the best Mac games available for Apple fans.
Product Review

Meet Z6, the breakout star in Nikon's new mirrorless lineup

The Nikon Z6 is the sibling to the new mirrorless Z7 -- but for some photographers, the cheaper Z6 may be the better option. Read where the $2,000 camera beats the $3,400 one (and where it doesn’t) in our Nikon Z6 review.

Turn your Raspberry Pi into a Steam streaming hub with Valve’s Steam Link app

Valve's Steam Link app is now fully supported by Raspberry PI hardware, meaning that just about anyone with a few dollars to spare can build their own Steam streaming box in a matter of minutes.

Nintendo pulls the plug on making more SNES Classic, NES Classic systems

Nintendo extended production of the NES Classic and SNES Classic into 2018, but once the current supply of consoles is gone, the company won't be making more. Instead, you'll have to use Nintendo Switch Online.

Fancy ‘Kingdom Hearts III’ PlayStation 4 Pro launches alongside game in January

A limited edition PlayStation 4 Pro bundle for Kingdom Hearts III will launch alongside the game in January. The system included has a special design on the side, as does the controller.

Want to share your Xbox One games? Here's how to do it

Sharing games on modern consoles is possible, but it takes a few steps. Here's how to start sharing games on your Xbox One console, so friends and family can easily access your library.

Here's where Xur is and what he has for wares this week in 'Destiny 2: Forsaken'

The weekly vendor in Destiny 2: Forsaken always brings Exotic weapons and armor, some of the toughest loot to find in the game. Here's everything you need to know to track down Xur: Where he is, when he shows up, and what he's stocking.

‘Fortnite’ removes the Infinity Blade weapon after player backlash

Following player backlash over the Infinity Blade weapon's inclusion in Fortnite's battle royale mode, Epic Games decided to remove the weapon from the game completely. It was not limited to a special mode.

Want every suit in 'Marvel's Spider-Man' for PS4? Here's how to get them all

Marvel's Spider-Man features a whopping 33 different suits for Peter Parker to wear as he swings across New York City knocking out baddies. Here are all the suits and how to unlock them.

Everything about 'Red Dead Online', including its new microtransaction store

Red Dead Online will gradually rolled out to Red Dead Redemption 2 players via a beta. We've got all the details about the beta's suite of competitive and cooperative modes, as well as what to expect going forward.

HDR monitors are beginning to have an impact. Here are the best you can buy

HDR isn't the most common of PC monitor features and is often charged at a premium, but the list of available options is growing. These are the best HDR monitors you can buy right now.
Virtual Reality

Oculus Rift vs. HTC Vive: Prices drop, but our favorite stays the same

The Oculus Rift and HTC Vive are the two big names in the virtual reality arena, but most people can only afford one. Our comparison tells you which is best when you pit the Oculus Rift vs. HTC Vive.