A slew of shill reviews for Wal-Mart's Straight Talk cell service have us questioning whether the name could get any more ironic.

After garnering the ire of consumers with unlimited data plans that aren’t actually unlimited, Wal-Mart’s low-cost carrier Straight Talk has belied its name yet again with an even shadier marketing strategy: shill reviews.

While we’re used to spam from the likes of tiny companies that need every eye they can get, we were surprised this morning when Digital Trends saw a bombardment of shill reviews promoting Straight Talk – a prepaid cellular service backed by giants Trac-Fone and Wal-Mart.

A flurry of “reviews” under different usernames left brief comments on the phones in question followed by hyperbolic raves about the wonders of Straight Talk. While we’ve since removed them, our research on the company churned up a slew of complaints about poor customer service, days spent without cell phone service while the carrier attempted to port over an old number, and even PIN numbers that scratch off airtime cards with the scratchoff material above them, leaving users out the money they paid for them.

Although TracFone has earned a solid reputation in the past, we recommend folks read our full guide to prepaid cell phones to learn about many of the hidden pitfalls to prepaid providers.

Showing 20 comments

  1. Consumer Alert: Wal-Mart Spams Straight Talk at 6:03am 28th October 2011 Consumer Alert: Wal-Mart Spams Straight Talk...[...]A slew of shill reviews for Wal-Mart's Straight Talk cell service have us questioning whether the name could get any more ironic.[...]...
  2. rl2336 at 1:21pm 3rd April 2011 BYER BEWARE !!!!WHAT A CRAPPY PHONE SERVICE.IM IN NASHVILLE,TN AND HAVE A STRAIGHT TALK PHONE THAT HAS A SIM CARD IN IT WHICH RESTRICTS WHERE YOU CAN USE THE PHONE.THEY DON BOTHER TO LET YOU KNOW THERE IS SIM CARD PHONE AREA MAP AND THE A NON-SIM PHONE AREA MAP.I USED THEIR NEW SERVICE WHERE YOU STORE YOUR RENEWAL CARD TO GO INTO SERVICE WHEN THE CARD YOU ARE USING EXPIRES,AND GUESS WHAT-IT DIDNT TRANSFER OVER AND NOW I MUST WAIT 24-48 HOURS WHILE THE FIGURE OUT WHAT THE PROBLEM IS.THINK LONG AND HARD BEFORE BUYING THIS PRODUCT.
  3. samschicky at 8:22am 17th March 2011 TERRIBLE!! I purchased a Straight Talk phone and a $45.00 service card. After just a couple days I was unhappy with the phone and service and switched my number and service to a new provider. Since there was already time (that I purchased) on the phone, and there was nothing wrong with the phone I decided not to let it go to waste and get the Straight Talk phone turned back on with a new number.
    1. samschicky at 8:22am 17th March 2011 (continued) I was then informed I needed to purchase ANOTHER service card to reactivate! The original one I bought was good until April 6! Should still be good! They tell me that because I ported my number to another phone, I basically just GAVE them $45.00! THEIVES
  4. mrmstory at 4:35pm 30th September 2010 I feel as though I'm stuck in a BAD movie! Have had Straight Talk for nearly a year. Roughly two months ago, I let my bill lapse for not quite one month. When I re-activated the phone, I was assigned a new number. Not a big deal at the time as I'd only used the phone for personal use. Since turning the phone back on, however, I've started to use it in my business. I've ordered all new business cards, marketing materials, and updated my websites and all peripherals with the "new" number. Yesterday, I tried to log into my account to find out when my bill was due... I kept getting a message that stated that my phone number was "inactive". I knew that it wasn't as I have been using the phone on a daily basis. I decided that I should at least make a payment on the phone as it should be due. When I completed the transaction online, I noticed that the payment was credited to a different phone number than I had... NOW, the nightmare begins.... I called customer service. (First Mistake)... After a very patient CS rep calmly explained to me SEVERAL times that the number that I was calling from couldn't be correct because that number was "inactive" in their system, she finally understood that they MAY have a problem in their system... She then hung up on me... I called customer service back (Second Mistake)... This time, after the CS agent explained to me that I couldn't be calling from that number because it was "inactive", we were able to get down to fixing it... After over an hour on the phone this time, she de-activated my phone and re-activated it with the correct number... WRONG!!!!!! I now have ANOTHER number.... She then hung up on me.... I called customer service back (Third Mistake)... THIS TIME, after arguing about my "inactive number", I asked for a supervisor. Over the next two and a half hours, he then helped me out by de-activating and re-activating my phone with the correct number... WRONG!!!!!!!!! I now have ANOTHER NEW NUMBER!!!!! The supervisor then explained to me that this was a "temporary" number until the correct one was ported over to the phone. He advised that I wait until morning and try re-setting the phone and it should work.... This morning, and several times throughout the day, I've "re-set" the phone to no avail... I still don't have the correct number... I sent an email to Customer Service (Fourth Mistake)... I explained everything to them that had happened. Asked very politely if they could just put the number back that THEY had given me and make sure that it was updated in my account... The reply that I got back from them was that they tried to call me to discuss the issue, but THEY DON"T HAVE A VALID PHONE NUMBER FOR ME!!!!! I'm now a wits end... I've had 3 different phone numbers in the past 24 hours. Now, when I log into my account, it shows that my phone is in the process of being activated and that there is no phone number associated with my account, however, my account IS current and doesn't expire until next month! If you're looking for cell service "on the cheap", Straight Talk is for you... If you'd like ANY resemblance of customer service, professionalism, or clarity, I'd look elsewhere... At this point, I'm going to try to continue working it out with them, hopefully I'll have good news to follow-up with!
  5. Julia at 8:53am 27th September 2010 I've had no problems at all with my Straight Talk at all. Phone works just fine and i've saved a load of cash with my $45 unlimited plan. I talk and text freely without worrying about a thing! I recommend the service wholeheartedly!
  6. KEEKEE at 8:17am 10th September 2010 Hi, everyone I had problems to with straighttalk but this is one number you can called that will answer right away and is very helpful in providing you will all the right information this number is tracfone customer service 18008765753. DO NOT CALLED 611 OR STRAIGHTTALK PERIOD. THEY DO NOT KNOW WHAT THEY DOING AND ALL THE REPRESENTATIVES GIVE YOU DIFFERENT INFORMATION.
  7. Richard at 7:38pm 30th August 2010 Had an existing ST phone but with very primitive features so purchased a new GSM phone with new SIM card. Called ST to upgrade phone, instead they deactivated old phone and new phone SIM card and said to wait up to 7 days without any service event though I purchased a new PIN card. What a joke. The customer service had to place me on hold almost 30 times to go back and forth to relay what I was saying and to relay what they were saying to me. After spending almost half day and the customer service kept repeating the same thing over and over again and not understanding what I was saying, I got no where. The customer service said that the new SIM card will be mailed to you and you have to wait meanwhile without service with both new and old phones useless. Absolutely horrible service, very unreliable. I feel sorry to have gone for ST.
  8. Julia Taylor at 4:46pm 2nd August 2010 BE VERY CAREFUL!!!! I used a friend's debit card to pay for a one time monthly service for Straight Talk service in July. My friend's birthday is today - my phone received a Happy Birthday message today. Scary that they are accessing the data from these card transactions.
  9. woody hoskins at 3:11pm 13th July 2010 Be forewarned WARNING ripoff alert.....................
  10. Woody Hoskins at 3:10pm 13th July 2010 Do not use this Dis-service or be ripped off!!!!!!!!!!!! WARNING..................
  11. Woody Hoskins at 3:08pm 13th July 2010 I upgraded to a SCH451 specifically to upload photos to my computer via Bluetooth, went camping for 3 weeks came back bought a new 45.00 and could upload photos. Called customer dis-service and was told they no longer provided this service!. I guess when you are Walmart you can do as you please. UNLESS we do not use their phones or service!!!!!
  12. bill at 11:31am 6th July 2010 my purchase of a straigt talk phone was a total waste of time and money....no service...2nd time card took two days to credit my unlimited time......can not connect to an understandble english speaking person....reception was and is terrible...can not ;use ;phone for another carrier....donated it to the sea.......emailed walmart and they said the service was not there problem......
  13. sc225 at 10:41pm 5th July 2010 This has been the worst experience of my life!!! The PIN number I am supposed to use to activate my phone was PEELED OFF by the sticker and I have been waiting for 2 weeks to receive a response after faxing in a copy of my receipt, card, and serial number. I called today and was on the phone with customer service for ONE HOUR after telling me that I will get a package from Fed ex to send them back the card that I already sent them a copy of!!!!! terrrible terrible terrible hassle and I will NOT be using them!!
  14. happy at 6:40am 14th May 2010 I bought an lg straight talk phone 1 week ago and have had no problems.Phone was activated in less then 15 min. go on line to this, I called when I messed up filling out the forms online and when I called the man spoke GREAT english.he even did a test call to make sure everything was alright. .Ive had verizon since it was taken over by cellular one. They use verizon towers so I cant see why people are complaining.JBR your comment is bs youre saying if you were walmart you would drop them..........why dont you drop them if youre that unhappy hell the phones are cheap enough so that your not out of that much money.
  15. Alyviah at 12:18am 8th May 2010 I use Straight Talk & I love it. It's cheep & convienient - with out the worry of contracts.
    The customer service is out of control I will confirm, but you don't have to go though them in most cases, like the activation process. You can simply get online and do it. It's much faster than having to speak w/ a forigner. I read reviews about Straight Talk before going out and buying it (Like a good customer :) & found nothing but good reviews minus the customer service people - Big deal. It's better than TracFone and less expensive. Send as many text/calls as you want w/out the hastle of worrying about how many minutes you have left. 4-5 Stars in my opinion!
  16. JBR at 10:30am 5th May 2010 I've had numerous bad experiences with Straighttalk cell phones, more specifically with their customer service representatives. In fact, it'd gotten to the point where I'd go out of my way NOT to speak to them unless I absolutely had to. It's quite obvious they are not only poorly trained in customer service, but many their employees (I can only speak for the ones I've been in contact with, of course) seem to lack the necessary skills for anything, but sub-par customer-to-service communication.
    There have been times where I waited only hold for close to thirty minutes just to be told by an automated voice that "all circuits are busy" and how they "appreciate" my patience. And, once, when I asked to speak to a manager after a quite unsatisfactory performance by the representative I was placed with (we'd been on the line for 30 mins., fifteen of which was spent on hold after our initial greeting), he'd flat out refused--apparently his manager "didn't take customer calls."
    Just recently, I've bought a $45 unlimited service plan from Wal-Mart after I'd been told they could refill using my debit MasterCard (because it was out of funds) despite the fact that when I called to check my balance, I had twice-over the amount necessary for an automatic refill, not-to-mention the fact that before that they had my card registered online with an erroneous expiration date.
    Currently, I've paid for a months renewal using the service card I mentioned above, but it's saying I have insufficient funds to receive text or make calls. I've tried multiple times to get in contact with my service provider (despite my obvious distaste), but as of yet, I've simply be put on hold in the seldom instances when my calls aren't directly dropped...
    It's my personal opinion, that StraightTalk is not only a horrible service provider (in those instances when they do in fact provide service), but they're also a scam. They're milking honest, working people of their hard-earned money and providing little of what they claim to when they're not welshing on their promises. If I were Wal-Mart, I'd drop them, at least until they can actually provide what they're offering. Otherwise, it's just bad business.
  17. michaelgolder at 9:27am 3rd May 2010 straight talk phones are complete shit.. i get static.. and ofc i think this is their whole plan to unload shit phones. i tried to take it back to walmart but seeing a i lost the receipt i was screwed. I only bought two airtime cards. i got the initial one when i purchased the phone. good on paper. sure it's a great deal. but you get what you pay for. the guy at walmart said they piggybacked off of verizon. Well that's a big fricking lie. My reception was way better with a verizon phone. So now we get into the second phone card. So after my month was up i didn't get a card for a couple of days. I had to reactivate my phone. WOW this was a epic undertaking i couldn't beleive. If you call their customer service line you may no indoubt get "All circuits are busy" or you may get put on hold. I was put on hold on a sunday for 3 1/2 hours. Finally just hung up the phone. Then i reached someone sunday night. It was a indian chix i could barely understand. So she said and i quote. Sir you have to wait 24hours for you phone to activate. LOL so yeah get a Straighttalk phone. You'll be able to use it someday. I've sitting on 30 hours and still not working. also the phone number to straight talk isn't working. LOL this is Walmart at their finest
    1. Brad at 12:30pm 27th November 2010 I had Sprint for 10+ yrs & hated it. Dropped calls constantly & extended my plan every time I sneezed. Not sure what is going on with Straight talk complaints here? I bought one at Walmart & followed the instructions exactly as it said. I have had O problems & can Talk/Text all I want for $50.00 mos incl tax. Not sure about their customer service people as I have gratefully never needed them? No dropped calls no issues? They deduct my bill directly from my acct & it is as smooth as glass?? I honestly believe Cell Phone Agents write bad reviews about other companies just to keep everyone from jumping ship from their brand. Straight talk is a nice plan using Verizon coverage. There is nothing to loose & it does not come back to bite you. My only complaint is I want to upgrade to a bigger screen to read FB & Emails with - they need a couple of phones with larger screens not just the Qwerty stuff? BIGGER SCREENS ON PHONES PLEASE but great coverage & really good price! No brainer??
    2. Mallory at 1:38pm 29th November 2010 I have had straight talk since it came out and i have not had one problem with it at all, so personally i think you are a liar.
Close Suggestion One Quarter of Americans Turn to Cell Phones for News
View Article