Kred creator PeopleBrowsr fires back at Twitter and wins temporary restraining order

kred versus twitterPeopleBrowsr, the company responsible for the social analytics service Kred, has filed a complaint against Twitter in the hopes of being able to retain integration with the platform. This lawsuit is also among the first of its kind where a third-party business that invested “millions of dollars and thousands of hours of development time” is fighting back on Twitter’s own turf. And much to our surprise, PeopleBrowsr announced that it had won a temporary restraining order against Twitter.

The problem between Kred and Twitter comes down to the social network’s new restrictive policies that were recently announced and enforced. Plenty of controversy and outrage has circulated around restrictions imposed on access to Twitter’s API, as well as plenty of complaints about the lack of transparency about the types of companies that Twitter will make exceptions for. Twitter could limit tokens for one third-party developer, and turn around to accept a request to offer additional tokens to another. 

PeopleBrowsr, as stated in the complaint filed with the state of California, was about to have Twitter’s full Firehose (which means being able to pull the entire Twitter stream) access revoked by November 30, 2012 – which is tomorrow. PeopleBrowsr says that Kred would only have access to a fraction of the data, which would of course mean Kred scores connected to Twitter would be highly inaccurate.

There doesn’t appear to have been a breach of contract on PeopleBrowsr’s end, so the limited access that Twitter wants to impose comes from far left field. PeopleBrowsr was given a 90-day warning back in July, but the company emphasizes that it was notified without a valid explanation. In bold the complaint states, “Twitter Has Refused to Provide Any Substantive Rationale For Termination.” The only feedback Twitter offered was that the social network was moving toward using third-party syndication services, Gnip and DataSift, for feeding third-party developers with access to the Firehose. However the caveat with going through Gnip and DataSift is that the number of tweets that these syndication services offer PeopleBrowsr is quite limited.

Twitter did fire back with an opposition that sought to diminish PeopleBrowsr’s complaint. The rebuttal starts off by saying, “This is Contracts 101. Although PeopleBrowsr attempts to dress its case up as some sort of grand antitrust case, it is not.” According to Twitter the terms of the contract state that both parties negotiated on a year-by-year basis, and agreed on a 30-day notice should either party choose to terminate the contract. And in response to signing off on its syndication efforts, that move was chalked up to the reasoning that Twitter now has hundreds of companies who have access to Twitter’s Firehose, and to lighten the load of managing these clients Twitter has left that task up to Gnip and DataSift.

The social network doesn’t mince words regarding how it feels about the lawsuit. “What [PeopleBrowsr] is not free to do is insist that Twitter preserve forever its earlier business model, or continue to be bound by a contract that expired more than a year ago.” To conclude the point Twitter adds, “If PeopleBrowsr’s novel view of the law were correct, Twitter would be required to continue to do business with PeopleBrowsr forever. This is not the law.”

PeerIndex founder and CEO, Azeem Azhar’s opinion on the matter, which he told me, seems to support Twitter’s rebuttal half-way. I asked him if Twitter had a responsibility to keep its platform open, which Twitter apparently promised, but he says that Twitter doesn’t have that responsibility to developers. However he adds, “I think it is in their absolute best interests to create a thriving ecosystem of developers and making that ecosystem as accessible as possible. And for the primary reason – that is is in Twitter’s own interest.”

Azhar confirms that Peer Index’s relationship with Twitter has generally been positive. There are some limitations however, “that in some ways limit access to certain resources without authentication, but it still provides a reasonable level of access.” But on this tussle between PeopleBrowsr and Twitter, Azhar offers this parting thought:

“Any business needs to understand it’s reliance of particular suppliers. This is as true for the local gourmet hamburger restaurant as it is for us. Twitter provides data via its API and also via three resellers, DataSift, GNIP and Topsy which creates sum competition in the supply market.”

For the four years Twitter and PeopleBrowsr have worked together, PeopleBrowsr was paying approximately $1 million per year for full access to Twitter’s Firehose. Breaking down the payments might give you an idea about how much PeopleBrowsr’s business relied on Twitter alone; PeopleBrowsr was paying Twitter the greater of:

(a) a minimum monthly fee of $15,000, which would increase by $5,000 per month with a cap of $100,000, or

(b) 25 percent of PeopleBrowsr’s gross revenue, net of third party revenue share.

In the complaint, PeopleBrowsr makes some interesting claims that illustrate the complexity of this issue. First, there’s more than enough evidence to prove that PeopleBrowsr was entering into the partnership with Twitter with the full expectation that Twitter would be open to third-party developers. The complaint lists evidence of Twitter’s intent to be “open” on pages six through eight, which you can read through here. “Twitter has repeatedly and consistently promised that it would maintain an “open ecosystem” for its data, and that Twitter would not use its control over data to pick which companies can succeed and by removing access create losers,” the lawsuit reads.

But there’s the fiscal fall out for not only PeopleBrowsr, which invested “over $5 million and more than 30,000 hours developing products that rely on the full Firehose,” but also its clients. PeopleBrowsr lists six and seven figure contracts with companies including Strategic Technology Research, Radian6, and even Mashable. While PeopleBrowsr won the restraining order that prevents Twitter from cutting off access to the Firehose, it’s just a temporary solution. The hearing is scheduled for January 8, and should PeopleBrowsr lose it won’t only massively impact its business, but set a precedent for the other myriad of clients dependent on Twitter access. 

We’ve reached out to PeopleBrowsr and Twitter and will keep you updated with their responses.

Edit: Added comments by PeerIndex’s founder and CEO.

Social Media

This band owns Twitter, according to list of top accounts and tweets for 2018

What was the biggest buzz on Twitter in 2018? Twitter's 2018 Year in Review highlights the biggest tweets, accounts, and hashtags. The most-tweeted celebrities, movies, TV shows, athletes, politicians and more in Twitter's 2018 trends.
Movies & TV

The best shows on Netflix, from 'Haunting of Hill House’ to ‘Twilight Zone’

Looking for a new show to binge? Lucky for you, we've curated a list of the best shows on Netflix, whether you're a fan of outlandish anime, dramatic period pieces, or shows that leave you questioning what lies beyond.
Mobile

Verizon begins RCS messaging rollout with the Pixel 3 and Pixel 3 XL

What is RCS messaging? It's the successor to today's text messaging. It offers features like real-time audio, read receipts, and encryption, but adoption so far has been slow. Here's everything you need to know.
Social Media

Hotel chain offers an Instagram ‘sitter’ who will post photos for you

If the pressure to post stunning Instagram photos is ruining your vacations, then how about hiring a local Instagram influencer to do the job for you while you go off and enjoy yourself? Well, such a service now exists.
Social Media

Ride the rails and share your stories with Amtrak’s new social media residency

Amtrak is looking for travel fans with a knack for telling stories on social media. The new Amtrak social media residency program wants amateur travelers to share photos, video, and written content from aboard long-distance trips.
Social Media

Hangouts isn’t being hung out to dry in 2020, Google says

According to a report, Google may shut down Google Hangouts by 2020. While Hangouts was once Google's top-tier messaging app, the app has since been neglected in favor of Android Messages.
Social Media

Tumblr bans nudity to create ‘a safe place for creative expression’

Tumblr will soon no longer allow images with adult content. The company says the change is one that's designed to help more creators feel comfortable sharing on the platform, but admits the change won't happen overnight.
Social Media

Members can share the same Story with Facebook’s new Group Stories

Facebook Group members can now view and share Group Stories. Unlike the Stories for an individual user, the new tool allows members to contribute to the same Group Story, if the feature isn't turned off by an admin.
Social Media

You can now share saved Facebook posts with a Pinterest-like collection tool

Facebook collections can now be shared with friends if you also want to allow them to contribute to the list. Facebook is rolling out an update that allows users to add a contributor to their collections, or lists of saved Facebook posts.
Mobile

Broadway actor tells Kanye West to get off his phone during opening night

Theater actors can get understandably upset when they spot someone in the audience fiddling with their phone instead of watching the show. The other night that audience member was Kanye West, and he got called out for it.
Social Media

This event topped Facebook’s biggest moments of the year — again

As the year comes to a close, Facebook is looking back on what users discussed most over the last year. For two years in a row, International Women's Day topped the list. So what else is on the list?
Social Media

What do yodeling and Kylie Jenner have in common? YouTube’s top 2018 videos

In a true nod to the variety found on YouTube, the platform's top 10 list of videos from 2018 range from celebrities to sports, from perfectly tossing a picture frame on the wall to a kid yodeling in aisle 12 at Walmart.
Home Theater

It took Tom Cruise to raise awareness of this troublesome TV setting

Tom Cruise, in an unexpected PSA tweet, asks you to turn off motion interpolation on your TV, but stops short of how to do it. Here's more on the topic, along with links to a guide on how to rid your TV of the dreaded "soap opera effect."
Computing

Make a GIF of your favorite YouTube video with these great tools

Making a GIF from a YouTube video is easier today than ever, but choosing the right tool for the job isn't always so simple. In this guide, we'll teach you how to make a GIF from a YouTube video with our two favorite online tools.