Are Ultrabooks already dead, or just waiting to arrive?

Ultrabook (general)

As smartphones and tablets chewed up the market for PCs back in 2011, chipmaking giant Intel made a bold bet to save its core business. Intel poured $300 million dollars into making notebook PCs lighter and thinner, dubbing the resulting products Ultrabooks.  Unlike chintzy, low-cost netbooks that offered a barebones computing experience on a small screen, Ultrabooks were supposed to pack the wallop and battery life of a mainstream notebook, but with a form factor that make them almost as easy to carry around as a tablet.

Sounds great, right? At the time, Intel boldly forecast that by the end of 2012 it hoped the Ultrabook platform would represent 40 percent of all consumer laptops — and Intel’s director of Ultrabook marketing stuck to that forecast as recently as last month.

But a year later, there’s no sign consumers or businesses are embracing Ultrabooks. Has the platform fizzled out, or is it just yet to arrive?

What is an Ultrabook?

are ultrabooks dead yet intel feature square

An Ultrabook isn’t a particular computer or line of computers — it’s just a notebook that meets particular design specs set out by Intel. So far, Intel has laid out two sets of criteria for what constitutes an Ultrabook:

First generation Ultrabooks needed to be based on Intel’s Sandy Bridge processors, offer at least five hours of battery life, and wake from deep sleep in no more than seven seconds. The systems must also include Intel management tools and both anti-theft and identity protection technology. Ultrabooks with 13.3-inch displays and smaller could only be 18mm thick — that’s 7/10 of an inch. Ultrabooks with 14-inch and larger displays could scale up to 21mm thick.

Second generation Ultrabooks retain all the specs of the first generation but move up to Intel’s more-recent Ivy Bridge processors (basically, packing better graphics and smaller size, so they use less power). Second-gen Ultrabooks also require USB 3.0 and have a minimum internal transfer rate for storage of 80MB/s. Notebooks that can be used as either a traditional laptop or flip around to become touch tablet can be up to 23mm thick (0.91 inches) and still be called an Ultrabook.

Plenty of things aren’t specified here. For instance, there’s no requirement for RAM or storage (whether hard drives, SSD, or a mix). Second-generation Ultrabooks require USB 3.0 (native in Intel’s Ivy Bridge processors) but there are no other connectivity or output requirements: Ethernet, Wi-Fi, Bluetooth, eSATA, HDMI, DisplayPort, Thunderbolt — those things and more or all left to computer makers’ discretion. Similarly, screensize is left up in the air, although Ultrabooks’ slim-and-sleek requirements are friendlier to ultraportables rather than notebooks with 15-inch or larger screens. Intel’s processors all come with onboard graphics, but there’s nothing to prevent computer makers from adding high performance third-party graphics — if they can cram them within the space and power requirements. Similarly, there’s no weight requirement.

In other words, Ultrabooks might be a brand, but there’s lots of room for variation — and confusion — about what they offer. For most people, the key word is “thin.”

How have Ultrabooks done?

The first Ultrabooks went on sale about a year ago, with second-generation models appearing on shelves in May and June of this year. By most standards, that’s enough time to gauge how consumers are responding to Ultrabooks. However, computer makers haven’t been breaking out Ultrabook sales separately from their sales of other notebook types, so few direct sales number are available.

What we do know doesn’t paint a rosy picture. In June — just as the second-generation Ultrabooks were starting to hit the market — IDC analyst Jay Chou indicated roughly half a million Ultrabooks had been sold during the first half of 2012, with expectations that a million might be sold by the end of the year.

IHS iSuppl ultrabooks forecast Oct 2012

IHS iSuppli was offering much more enthusiastic estimates of Ultrabook shipments, forecasting that 22 million units would ship by the end of 2012. However, this week IHS iSuppli cut its near-term forecast on Ultrabook sales roughly in half, instead calling for 10.3 million units to ship during 2012. In 2013, IHS iSuppli expects computer makers to ship 44 million Ultrabooks — a big number, but still lower than their previous forecast of 61 million units.

Estimates earlier this year from IDC and Gartner forecast the worldwide market for notebook computer would be between 220 and 230 million units; IDC recently revised that estimate downward to 214 million units. By Chou’s mid-year estimate, that would put Ultrabook sales at less than one half of one percent of notebook computers worldwide for 2012; iSuppli’s forecast would have Ultrabooks accounting for less than five percent of notebook sales worldwide.

Both figures would be a long way from the 40 percent of consumer notebook sales Intel was hoping for by the end of 2012.

Is it all about price?

Ivy Bridge

The most common complaint about Ultrabooks is that they’re simply too expensive. Intel had hoped Ultrabooks would go on sale at prices under $1,000, but some Ultrabooks trend far north of that: HP’s Envy 14 Spectre had a $1,400 starting price, and LG’s X-Note Z330 Ultrabook started at $1,500. A few systems cracked the $1,000 barrier (notably the Acer Aspire S3-951 and HP Folio 13) — but high Ultrabook prices are the norm, not the exception.

High prices for Ultrabooks puts the products between a rock and a hard place. Due to their thin form factors and svelte power requirements, they often sport comparatively small screens (13- and 14-inch screens with 1,366 x 768 resolution is the norm, although a couple like the Asus Zenbook Prime UX32VD scoot out to a full 1,920 x 1,080 pixels). The slim cases often mean few ports: Essentially all Ultrabooks sport USB and Wi-Fi, but if you need VGA output to drive a projector at a presentation, you’re probably out of luck. Similarly, all but a few (high end) Ultrabooks lack optical drives. For many users, that makes Ultrabooks comparable to with traditional ultraportable computers — thin, small screens, few ports — just more expensive. Given a choice between buying two computers with limited options, most businesses and consumers will go for the less-expensive one — and right now that’s rarely going to be the Ultrabook.

Prices are coming down on Ultrabook models: Acer and HP have started aggressively pricing low-end models below $700 — although right now those are models based on the first-generation Ultrabook spec, so they don’t necessarily represent the latest technology. They also ignore the unibody aesthetic Intel has been promoting for the brand: low-end Ultrabooks tend to sport a fair bit of plastic. Pricing on Ultrabooks based on the first-generation spec should dip below $600 by the end of the year — some deal sites are already on that threshold.

Long live the “ultrathin?”

HP Envy Sleekbook (AMD Trinity)

There’s no reason every thin notebook has to be an Ultrabook. In fact, the Intel’s Ultrabook effort has effectively created another category of notebooks dubbed “ultrathins” — notebooks that look an awful lot like Ultrabooks but don’t qualify for one reason or another. Maybe they’re just a smidge too thick because they include an optical drive or a VGA port, or maybe they’re based on AMD’s Trinity processor instead of Intel’s chips. Whatever the reason, they’re still thin and more portable than traditional notebooks — and often cheaper than Ultrabooks.

In the long run, Intel might be just fine with that.

“Whether or not the system is an “Ultrabook” or not, in the long run, may not be a worry for Intel. What they want to accomplish is getting the PC industry to innovate new designs and engineering (like ultrathin, ultralight, convertibles, touch screen, etc.) that will better compete with the other new computing gadgets (like the tablet or smartphone),” said IHS iSuppli’s Craig Stice, via email. “If the PC industry can accomplish this and continue to grow (with or without the need for a branded Ultrabook), the PC industry and Intel wins.”

Are Ultrabooks about to take off?

windows 8 tablet netbook

Another reason Ultrabooks have been slow to engage is that the personal computer market has been essentially flat this year, as consumers drift towards smartphones and tablets and many would-be buyers are putting off purchasing new gear until they see what Windows 8 will bring them.

If Windows 8 resonates with consumers, it may spark Ultrabook sales. The launch of Windows 8 is expected to usher in a new generation of Ultrabook products, many of which will be convertible tablets: They can be used like traditional clamshell notebooks, or detach their screens and function as touch-enabled tablets. At the Intel Developer Forum last month, the company reportedly claimed some 70 Ultrabook designs are in computer makers’ product pipelines, and 40 of them sport touchscreens.

Microsoft’s Windows 8 launch, and Microsoft’s corresponding marketing push, should expose Ultrabooks to more buyers. At the same time, first- and second-generation Ultrabook models will likely come down in price, potentially bringing additional interest from consumers are well as businesses that have been putting off new computer purchases.

Looking forward, the next revision of Intel’s Ultrabook specification — which will be based on Intel’s upcoming Haswell processor — is expected to land in mid-2013. Haswell will be the first processor chip Intel has actually designed with the Ultrabook platform in mind: They’ll have even lower power consumption than current Ivy Bridge processors, and Intel is working on an even lower-power version designed with convertible tablets in mind. Haswell-based Ultrabooks will also feature scalable graphics (including support for DisplayPort 1.2 and 4K video output).

However, these Haswell-based systems are likely to debut at the high end of notebook pricing — just like most of today’s Ultrabooks — which means they may face the same issues.

Bottom line

Intel is not going to give up on Ultrabooks. In fact, you can expect the company to push the platform even harder with the launch of Windows 8 this month and the debut of Haswell processors in mid-2013. However, the leading edge of Ultrabooks are almost certainly going to remain specialized products with high price tags. If Ultrabooks ever go mainstream — and capture that 40 percent of the consumer notebook market Intel expects — it will be because prices on previous generations of Ultrabooks have fallen to points where they can successfully compete against traditional notebooks and ultrathins.

Computing

Get a new 2018 Apple MacBook Air for $1,000 with Amazon’s latest sale

Online retailer Amazon is currently running a discount on select models of the MacBook Air 2018. You can bring one home starting at $1,000, a full $200 off the usual selling price.
Computing

In 2019, laptops are better than ever. Here are the best of the best

The best laptop should be one that checks all the boxes: Great battery life, beautiful design, and top-notch performance. Our picks for the best laptops you can buy do all that — and throw in some extra features while they're at it.
Deals

From Chromebooks to MacBooks, here are the best laptop deals for March 2019

Whether you need a new laptop for school or work or you're just doing some post-holiday shopping, we've got you covered: These are the best laptop deals going right now, from discounted MacBooks to on-the-go gaming PCs.
Computing

Tablet or notebook? Our favorite 2-in-1 PCs give you the best of both worlds

If you can’t decide if you need a tablet or a notebook, then don’t bother. The best 2-in-1 laptops are both, and they can provide all the power you need. Check out our list for the best 2-in-1s for any user.
Mobile

Want to watch Netflix in bed or browse the web? We have a tablet for everyone

There’s so much choice when shopping for a new tablet that it can be hard to pick the right one. From iPads to Android, these are our picks for the best tablets you can buy right now whatever your budget.
Computing

Man pleads guilty to scamming Facebook and Google out of more than $100M

One of the men behind an elaborate fraud that saw Facebook and Google each hand over tens of millions of dollars has admitted to his part in the scheme. Lithuanian Evaldas Rimasauskas faces up to 30 years in a U.S. jail.
Product Review

HP’s gem-cut Spectre x360 15 is the most powerful 2-in-1 you can buy

HP’s 2019 Spectre x360 15 brings this massive 2-in-1 up to speed, literally. It now equips the same six-core Intel CPU as the rest of the 15-inch field, along with a real GPU for some 1080p gaming.
Computing

Ditch the background from your photos with these handy editing tools

Need to know how to remove the background from an image? Whether you prefer to use a premium program like Photoshop or one of the many web-based alternatives currently in existence, we'll show you how.
Computing

Yes, you can use Android apps on your Chromebook. Here's how

You can now get Android apps on your Chromebook! Google has enabled the Google Play Store app support on its Chrome OS and Chromebook hardware, so to get you started, here's our guide on how to get Android apps on a Chromebook.
Computing

Zipping files on a Chromebook? Follow these four easy steps

Chromebooks support file compression, though they work a little differently than on Windows or Mac. Here's the step-by-step process to zipping files on a Chromebook, and then unzipping them again for extraction.
Computing

Tired of all that white? Here's how to change the Google background image

Did you know that you can change how your Google search home page looks? It's a simple process to pick a new theme: We'll show you how to change your Google background, what to look for in themes, and how to download your own pictures for a…
Deals

These big, beautiful BenQ gaming monitors are on sale on Amazon right now

All gamers know that a good monitor is just as important as PC hardware to fully enjoy what today's games have to offer. BenQ makes some of the best (including some of our favorites), and three top-rated BenQ gaming monitors are on sale on…
Deals

The best Raspberry Pi 3 kits for coders, gamers, and DIY projects

The Raspberry Pi 3 is a low-budget computing platform capable of doing just about anything. We rounded up a handful of the best Raspberry Pi 3 bundles to get you started on a variety of DIY projects.
Computing

Need a portable workstation? One of these two 15-inch laptop might do the trick

HP's Spectre x360 15 is the most powerful 2-in-1 around, but it faces stiff large-laptop competition. Can it beat out powerful clamshells like well-built Apple MacBook Pro 15?