Wikipedia editors react: the SOPA blackout is wrong

neutralWe’ve all undoubtedly suffered a bit due to the Wikipedia blackout today. The site has censored itself to give the Internet a test of what the consequences of SOPA/PIPA regulations could look like. And while it’s inarguably effective and has created something of a rally cry among devoted Web users, some take issue with the tactic—specifically, Wikipedia editors.

“I think the Wikipedia blackout protest was a really bad idea,” editor Charles Ainsworth (whose user name on the site is Cla68) tells us. “Wikipedia is not supposed to get involved in political causes, it should remain neutral.”

An editor by the name of User:Scott ManDonald has made a Wikipedia entry (irony of ironies) detailing this ethical gray area. In an entry titled “Wikipedia should remain ideology-free: Protecting the death of a neutral community,” he writes: “The blackout of the English Wikipedia destroys forever the concept of its political and geographic neutrality. It means rather than an open group of international contributors, uniting solely around their commitment to writing an encyclopedia, with nothing else implied, Wikipedia is, through what can only be described as an Internet moral panic, now associated with a particular political position in a particular national.”

“While many, possibly most, Wikipedians may happen to hold this political position in common, it ought to have been irrelevant to editing here. Now it is not; a precedent has been set and something important has died,” he says.

Wikipedia founder Jimmy Wales has been tied to controversy before, and in the wake of being labeled overly-partisan, has defended his position. “Articles must remain neutral. The community need not, not when the future of the Internet is at stake,” he says via Twitter.

Wikipedia’s efforts today have been successful—both in raising awareness regarding SOPA/PIPA and bringing attention to the site. But other platforms have shied from taking a stance, most notably Twitter. “Closing a global business in reaction to a single-issue national politics is foolish,” CEO Dick Costollo says, although noting he meant strictly in reference to his company.

So what do we lose? Wikipedia is inarguably helping the anti-SOPA cause: lawmakers supporting the bill, including two co-sponsors, have dropped their support. There’s been a massive rallying cry and Wikipedia has been one of the organizations at the helm–but there is a cost. That cost comes in the form of doubt over the site’s invaluable neutrality. An encyclopedia isn’t a place where you want opinions, and Wikipedia has spent so much time cultivating itself as a worthy source – a community that users trust to present facts.

If you never felt this way about Wikipedia, then you weren’t all that affected by its blackout, or you use it quite casually and simply took something away from its protest. Still, taking a stance has consequences for those who see it as a neutral quarry of information. But you have to weigh that against the outcome, and movement that can turn the political tide against SOPA/PIPA is also a valuable thing. As Wikimedia staffer Brandon Harris told us, “Overall, the citizens of planet Earth seemed pretty excited and positive, so that’s a good thing, I think.”


Firefox Reality wants to bring the ‘whimsical web’ to VR

Mozilla launched a VR-powered web browser today called Firefox Reality. But just what does browsing the web in VR feel like? We went hands-on with this new browser to see how Mozilla imagines the future of virtual reality content.
Movies & TV

Save a few bucks with the best free feature-length movies on YouTube

Bank account emptier than you thought? Check out our curated list of the best full-length movies on YouTube to find feature-length flicks that are free, legally uploaded, and actually worth watching.
Movies & TV

'Prime'-time TV: Here are the best shows on Amazon Prime right now

Amazon Prime brings more perks than just free two-day shipping. Subscribers get access to a huge library of TV shows to stream at no extra cost. Here are our favorite TV shows currently available on Amazon Prime.

Your PlayStation 4 game library isn't complete without these games

Looking for the best PS4 games out there? Out of the massive crop of titles available, we selected the best you should buy. No matter what your genre of choice may be, there's something here for you.

These are the best Xbox One games out right now

More than four years into its lifespan, Microsoft's latest console is finally coming into its own. From 'Cuphead' to 'Halo 5,' the best Xbox One games offer something for everyone.

YouTube has a new destination for gamers as it plans to shutter gaming app

YouTube is shuttering its gaming app early next year and turning its attention to developing a brand-new gaming destination on its main site. The app launched in 2015 as part of efforts to take on video-gaming platform Twitch.
Smart Home

Is Amazon tweaking its search algorithms with a new A.I.-driven shopping site?

Amazon is testing a new shopping site, Amazon Scout, which combines a visual aesthetic with customers' ability to like and dislike products, collecting more data on users' habits and preferences.

Newegg was cracked, customer data has leaked, and security is clearly scrambled

Online electronics retailer Newegg has found themselves at the heart of an online security breach as the company's payment system was breached, giving hackers of the notorious group, Magecart, potential access to confidential customer data…

Smart Reply not smart enough? Desktop Gmail users can soon opt out

Google will soon give desktop Gmail users the ability to opt out of Smart Reply. If you'd prefer to compose a short email the old-fashioned way, you can do so without seeing the auto-generated suggestions in the future.

Edit, sign, append, and save with 12 of the best PDF editors

There are plenty of PDF editors to be had online, and though the selection is robust, finding a solid solution with the tools you need can be tough. Here, we've rounded up best PDF editors, so you can edit no matter your budget or OS.

Ripple cryptocurrency jumps 70 percent in 24 hours after news of bank deal

The Ripple cryptocurrency has seen its value reach the highest point since late 2017 after a tease from a Ripple Labs regulator suggested it could soon be adopted by banks for international money transfers.

From beautiful to downright weird, check out these great dual monitor wallpapers

Multitasking with two monitors doesn't necessarily mean you need to split your screens with two separate wallpapers. From beautiful to downright weird, here are our top sites for finding the best dual monitor wallpapers for you.

It's not all free money. What to know before you try to mine Bitcoin

Mining Bitcoin today is harder than it used to be, but if you have enough time, money and cheap electricity, you can still turn a profit. Here's how to get started mining Bitcoin at home and in the cloud.

Bing, Windows search evolve into new, cross-platform Microsoft Search

Microsoft is upgrading its various search tools to provide more contextual help for those seeking it. Bing, Office, and Windows search will all be upgraded over the coming months to provide much more nuanced results.