Studios take on DVD copying

Chesterfield, Mo.-based 321 Studios has sold about a half-million copies of its software titles that allow the user to make backup copies of DVD movies to blank DVDs or CDs. Hollywood alleges the company’s software functions in a way that is prohibited by the Digital Millennium Copyright Act of 1998, signed into law by Hollywood-friendly former President Clinton.

The DMCA prohibits the circumvention of technological measures put in place by content owners to protect access to copyright works.

The software company says its products merely give consumers fair use of the movies they’ve purchased — backing up expensive copies of children’s movies or copying snippets of films for educational and journalistic use.

But the traditional fair-use doctrine in this case has given way to making DVDs fair game for movie piracy, Hollywood lawyers contend.

“Clearly, 321 does not think of fair use,” attorney Russell Frackman argued on behalf of the studios. “What 321 sells is a commercial circumvention product.”

Frackman is a veteran of such copyright issues, having led the music industry to a courtroom victory over Napster, the song-swapping company that folded under legal pressure.

Daralyn Durie, the lawyer for 321 Studios, told U.S. District Judge Susan Illston the portion of the company’s software that defeats the underlying access code to movies, the Content Scramble System or CSS, makes the product nothing more than a DVD player at heart.

“What a DVD player does and what our product does are exactly the same thing,” Durie said. “The question here is not whether we have the authority. It’s whether the users have the authority to access the content.”

The CSS scheme included on most Hollywood-produced DVDs requires a software key inside hardware players to access the underlying movie content. Frackman argued that 321 Studios has no right to distribute that key in its software, but he sought to deflect any notion that Hollywood was calling consumers movie thieves.

“It’s not a copyright case. It’s not a case against the user,” Frackman told the court. “It is precisely the type of case Congress foresaw, predicted and legislated.”

Judge Illston said she already had been persuaded by the previous ruling in the Universal City Studios vs. Corley case and was looking to it for guidance in the DVD case. In the Corley matter, the 2nd U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals in New York ruled in favor of nine major Hollywood studios that sought to force Eric Corley, operator of the 2600 Magazine Web site, to remove links to a DVD decryption program.

But Illston grilled Hollywood’s lawyers on the time limitations of copyright materials and how those rights may be effectively extended by virtue of the CSS code contained on DVD discs. If the copyright for a movie lapses, she asked, doesn’t it live on indefinitely by continually preventing the owner of a DVD from accessing the movie as he or she sees fit?

Mark Radcliffe, an attorney on intellectual property who is not involved in the case, said the entertainment industry may be pushing too hard to protect its content.

“Copyright is only supposed to grant enough rights to make works available to the public,” he said. “They’ve taken a much more absolutist position that copyright is some sort of birthright.”

He added that the case may hinge on how people are actually using 321 Studio’s software — whether indeed the company can prove that scratched or worn DVDs are truly a problem for consumers.

Cindy Cohn, legal director for the Electronic Frontier Foundation, also said Hollywood is extending its control a bit too far into the consumer arena. The EFF has filed a brief in support of 321 Studio’s position.

If the studios prevail, the consumer’s right to fair use of media content will surely suffer, Cohn said. Licensing agreements to provide descrambling keys only to certain hardware makers could leave consumers on the fringe, with fewer options for accessing their movies.

“The copyright owners get to move into the 21st century and the consumers are left with horses and buggies,” Cohn said.


Tidal faces legal jeopardy over fake stream numbers accusation

In another challenging chapter for music subscription service Tidal, Norwegian authorities have begun a formal investigation into charges that the company faked millions of streams for artists such as Kanye West and Beyoncé.
Home Theater

The best movies on Netflix in December, from 'Buster Scruggs’ to 'Roma'

Save yourself from hours wasted scrolling through Netflix's massive library by checking out our picks for the streamer's best movies available right now, whether you're into explosive action, witty humor, or anything else.
Movies & TV

The best shows on Netflix, from 'Haunting of Hill House’ to ‘Norsemen’

Looking for a new show to binge? Lucky for you, we've curated a list of the best shows on Netflix, whether you're a fan of outlandish anime, dramatic period pieces, or shows that leave you questioning what lies beyond.

Among hundreds of choices, these are the best 25 SNES games of all time

The Super Nintendo Entertainment System might be the greatest game console ever made, but what are the best titles for the system? Here are our picks for the best SNES games.
Movies & TV

Epic sci-fi novels you should read before they become blockbuster films

You can get ahead of the next crop of science-fiction movies coming out of Hollywood by picking up the books that inspired them. We compiled a list of books you can add to your reading list now to get a glimpse of the future.
Home Theater

Throw away those EarPods -- we dug up the best headphones in every style

Trolling the internet for hours to find headphones is no way to live. Instead, leverage our expertise and experience to find the best headphones for you. Here are our 10 favorites.
Home Theater

Sony’s 360 Reality Audio is the epic sound revolution you didn’t know you needed

After Sony’s utterly bizarre press conference, I almost missed what was perhaps the most impactful sonic experience at the show. Luckily, I went back to Sony’s booth on the last day of the show, only to have my mind blown.
Home Theater

Need to get rid of an unused Netflix profile? Just follow these simple steps

Need to delete an unwanted profile from your Netflix account? It's easy to do, no matter what kind of equipment you've got. Check out our handy how-to guide for step-by-step instructions.
Home Theater

The seven best TVs you can buy right now, from budget to big screen

Looking for a new television? In an oversaturated market, buying power is at an all-time high, but you'll need to cut through the rough to find a diamond. We're here to help with our picks for the best TVs of 2019.

Beam up the videos: AirPlay support is coming to VLC player

At CES 2019, the developers of VLC player announced they are adding support for Apple's Airplay feature, allowing consumers to beam video and other content from their iPhone and Android devices to an Apple TV. 
Home Theater

Not chill: Netflix is hiking prices across all its tiers

Netflix has to get the billions of dollars it's spending on new content from somewhere. The streaming giant announced price hikes across the board, raising its monthly rates between $1 and $2 per tier in the next few months.
Home Theater

Here’s why you’re not getting Netflix in HD or 4K, and how to fix it

Are you having trouble watching your favorite movies or TV shows on Netflix in HD or 4K? We explain why loading takes so long, why the picture quality fluctuates, and what you can do about it.
Home Theater

From the Roku Ultra to the Fire TV Cube, these are the best streaming devices

There are more options for media streamers than ever, so it’s more difficult to pick the best option. But that’s why we're here. Our curated list of the best streaming devices will get you online in no time.
Home Theater

Polk Audio’s Command Bar joins Alexa’s multiroom music party

Polk's Command Bar is a home theater soundbar with Alexa built in. But with a new update, it can also be grouped with Amazon's Echo products and other third-party speakers for a multi-room experience.